| "Rating anime is seriously a subjective thing. It all depends on the feelings and experiences u had during watching that particular anime. Even a bare minimum unpleasant experience while watching an anime could really affect your whole thought about the anime. It's all back to your enjoyment. If people don't enjoy your favorite anime, doesn't necessarily mean it's not good. It's just they had a different experience." -someone from Youtube wht are you guys opinion on this? |
 |
| My ratings are the result of both subjective and objective viewpoints, I do get where they're coming from tho |
 |
| Is it not? It's far better than being "objective". |
  |
| I agree with the general sentiment. There is a popular saying of "Timing is everything." There are optimal and suboptimal conditions when to watch certain shows. Determining optimal conditions are a bit tricky, but suboptimal conditions are easier. For example, I tend to enjoy less when I watch shows when I'm starving (some of my attention is diverted to my hunger and being hungry also makes me grouchy; which could lead me to take my displeasure on the show) or really sleepy (the details of the show are blurred). |
 |
| Yes, rating is a very subjective thing that solely depends on each person. When it comes to watch an anime, it's always the enjoyment that matters the most. There will be always anime for everyone to like or enjoy. Personal experiences, preferences and feelings are quite prominent on how I rate shows too. Sometimes even if a show people considerd to be good, it could be opposite for me. So yeah I agree with your statement. |
  |
| Well yeah, people think differently, that's how opinions work after all. |
| This is objectively the truth. (pun intended) Why does this even need to be discussed... |
 |
| As usual, it depends from what we're talking about. The quality of animation doesn't depend on my mood. Redline isn't ugly when I'm not in the mood to watch it, and that horse scene from Spice and Wolf isn't good even when I'm feeling particularly lenient. Yes, your enjoyment of the final product is subjective. I enjoy titties. Does a show suddenly gets better with titties?... wait actually that's a wrong example, a good quarter of the anime fandom thinks titties = better. |
Prophetess of the Golden Era  |
| Yeah, people have opinions. One of my opinions is that I like K-On! |
    beep boop bop pow |
| I rate my anime based more on objectively rather than subjectively |
just a weeb wandering around.  |
| People like different things, pretty sure everyone knows that (At least I hope so.) |
 |
| That's bullshit. People who dislike my favs are stupid and they should eat some shit. |
| It's odd. Some in the anime community swear that it only matters how you feel about an anime but as soon as you say you don't like an anime they like then it becomes about how objectively good an anime is. This is kind of a trademark of toxic fandoms though. I personally think it's best to look at all media subjectively and objectively. Anime isn't some special case that can't be criticize objectively. Movies and art are looked at through critical lens using objective factors all the time, why should anime be any different? Though I will always say subjectivity > objectivity |
 |
hohofish said: That's bullshit. People who dislike my favs are stupid and they should eat some shit. based even more based than the character limit |
 'On-Hold' is another way for a completionist to say 'Dropped' |
| I prioritize enjoyment over narrative quality but everyone rates in different ways so idk |
 |
| I'm no critic, I'm not examining every little facet and detail of the structure of an anime. I'm just watching anime to have some form of escapism to look forward to at the end of the day after a long and tiring shift! I rate an anime ENTIRELY based on how much positive impact it had on me personally. I don't want to feel like I'm grading a student's essay, I want to, have a good time. Now if you want to be the critic, go ahead, it's free real estate, and no one can stop you on how you rate your stuff. But take into account rotten tomatoes, the CRITIC score is the face of the film, what you see first, and how you judge it. But after watching a movie, which rating do you tend to lean more towards? The critic or the audience? Don't know about you, but just about every time I agree with the audience score almost whole heartedly while thinking the critic score is bunch of bs At the end of the day it's up to you to decide how you judge your anime. As for me, I'm going to continue being a casual and just rating on how much I personally enjoyed what I watched |
  NYANPASU  whiskey tango foxtrot |
| i agree, it's all subjective.. but some anime shows are objectively dogshit |
More topics from this board
» Is the anime community "a classless society"?thewiru - Yesterday |
14 |
by BubblegumPatty
»»
2 minutes ago |
|
» Best anime from every rating you have given (1-10)?DarkFirefly72 - Yesterday |
13 |
by AverageRiceFan
»»
7 minutes ago |
|
» Why do babies in anime look like that?Lentus1 - 9 hours ago |
8 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
21 minutes ago |
|
» Do you look down on shounen fans? ( 1 2 3 )Dragevard - Mar 25 |
104 |
by Papa_Scorch
»»
22 minutes ago |
|
» Do you really like it when a hero protagonist in anime is funny or do you rather when he is serious?MegaMan1 - Yesterday |
17 |
by DesuMaiden
»»
22 minutes ago |